Executive Overview
The ballroom doors have closed for one of Dancing with the Stars’ most unexpected fan favorites. Following a hard-fought run that carried him through five intense weeks of competition, Jimmy Kimmel Live! sidekick Guillermo Rodriguez was officially eliminated during the October 13 episode of DWTS Season 35. Partnered with professional dancer Witney Carson—who notably competed while pregnant with her third child—Rodriguez captivated viewers far beyond the traditional metrics of technical ballroom precision.
Rather than mourning the exit as a defeat, late-night host Jimmy Kimmel transformed his nightly broadcast into a celebratory victory lap for his longtime colleague. Dedicating a substantial segment of his October 13 show to Rodriguez’s journey, Kimmel highlighted staggering internet engagement figures, including YouTube view counts that dwarfed those of fellow competitors by more than three times.
While the elimination marks the end of Rodriguez’s unexpected foray into competitive choreography, it underscores a broader shift in how reality television ecosystems operate. In an era where viral appeal, audience connection, and personality-driven narratives often rival raw technical execution, Rodriguez’s run stands as a masterclass in modern television engagement. This comprehensive report examines the chronology of his elimination, the digital metrics that defined his tenure, the emotional reactions from late-night television royalty, and a detailed look at the remaining roster of Season 35 contenders.
Detailed Chronology: Week 5 and the Road to Elimination
The trajectory of Season 35 of Dancing with the Stars has been characterized by intense competition, eclectic casting, and surprising audience alignments. From the season premiere, the inclusion of non-traditional dancers injected fresh energy into the ballroom, but few participants generated as much curiosity as the beloved late-night sidekick.
The Journey to Week Five
Paired with seasoned pro Witney Carson, Rodriguez entered the competition facing significant physical hurdles. Lacking formal dance training, his early weeks were defined by rigorous conditioning, steep learning curves, and comedic self-awareness. Yet, under Carson’s inventive choreography—which continually adapted to challenge and showcase her partner—Rodriguez progressed week after week, surviving multiple elimination rounds through a combination of sheer grit and massive public support.
By the time Week 5 arrived on October 13, the competition had narrowed. The technical standards demanded by the judges had escalated, leaving little room for error. Despite executing routines that brought undeniable joy to viewers at home, Rodriguez and Carson found themselves on the wrong side of the judges’ scores and viewer tallies, culminating in their emotional departure from the ballroom floor.
The On-Air Revelation
True to his comedic roots, Rodriguez maintained an optimistic and lighthearted perspective on his exit. When reflecting on what he had hoped to achieve when he first signed up for the punishing dance competition, his goals were refreshingly grounded.
"Jimmy, I said I was gonna lose weight, and I did lose weight," Rodriguez remarked during his post-elimination check-in, drawing laughs and admiration from both the studio audience and viewers nationwide.
For Carson, the journey was equally monumental. Pushing through the physical demands of the ballroom while pregnant with her third child, her ability to construct routines that kept Rodriguez competitive earned widespread critical praise from the television industry at large.
Supporting Context & Metrics: The Power of Viral Engagement
While technical scores from judges Derek Hough, Carrie Ann Inaba, and Bruno Tonioli often dictate the baseline of Dancing with the Stars, the ultimate arbiter of a celebrity’s longevity is the viewing public. In Season 35, Guillermo Rodriguez proved that digital footprint and cultural resonance can transcend traditional ballroom metrics.
Staggering Digital Metrics
During his October 13 monologue, Jimmy Kimmel pulled back the curtain on the show’s digital ecosystem, providing concrete data that illustrated Rodriguez’s dominance in the online sphere. Displaying analytics from YouTube, Kimmel revealed that routine clips featuring Rodriguez and Carson had racked up over 700,000 views.
To put this figure into perspective, Kimmel pointed out a striking statistical disparity:
- Guillermo & Witney’s View Count: Over 700,000 views
- Nearest Competitor’s View Count: Less than one-third of that total
This massive surge in digital engagement reflects a wider trend in contemporary television consumption. Viewers increasingly interact with content asynchronously through social media algorithms, YouTube shorts, and TikTok reels. Rodriguez’s inherent likability, combined with the novelty of his partnership with Carson, turned their weekly numbers into a viral phenomenon.
The Weight-Loss and Wellness Narrative
Beyond the metrics of viewership, Rodriguez’s participation highlighted the physical transformation often experienced by non-athlete contestants on the show. Reality dance competitions require an extraordinary level of cardiovascular endurance. For Rodriguez, who spent years behind a desk or roaming studio corridors on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the transition to daily dance rehearsals acted as a rigorous boot camp. His candid admission of achieving his personal fitness goals resonated with audiences tracking wellness milestones, elevating his narrative from a novelty act to a genuine personal triumph.
Official Statements and Late-Night Tributes
The elimination of a late-night sidekick from a major network dance competition might typically pass as a minor pop-culture footnote. However, the deep professional ties between Rodriguez and Jimmy Kimmel ensured that the exit received prime-time television real estate.
Jimmy Kimmel’s Monologue and Dial-In Tribute
Kimmel opened his October 13 show with high praise, framing the elimination not as a failure, but as the conclusion of an improbable triumph against the odds:
"Let’s get to the main event now. To the brightest star in all the universe, Guillermo, who has somehow against all odds made it to week five of Dancing with the Stars and is the toast of the internet."
Addressing the viral analytics head-on, Kimmel playfully celebrated his colleague’s digital supremacy before pivoting to the emotional reality of the departure. He also addressed a touching fan interaction from a young viewer who had written in to support Rodriguez while playfully inquiring if Kimmel served as his father.
"I am not Guillermo’s dad," Kimmel quipped to the studio audience. "लेकिन I am just as proud of him as I am of my own children."
When connecting via video call with Rodriguez and Carson later in the broadcast, Kimmel didn’t hold back his admiration for the pregnant pro dancer’s choreography.
"Witney, your choreography this season has been absolutely incredible," Kimmel mused. "The situations you’ve put Guillermo in—really, really impressive. I mean honestly, you’ve taken this lump of Play-Doh and you’ve sculpted him into a masterpiece."
Turning his attention back to Rodriguez, Kimmel delivered a quintessential late-night punchline:
"You have brought so much joy to so many and now we have nothing to look forward to ever again."
Season 35 Landscape: Who Remains on the Dancefloor?
With Guillermo Rodriguez’s departure, Season 35 of Dancing with the Stars marches forward with a diverse and competitive roster of celebrities, athletes, and social media personalities. As the competition heats up in the wake of Week 5, the remaining couples are jockeying for position to claim the coveted Mirrorball Trophy.
Here is a comprehensive breakdown of the stars and professional partners still holding down the dancefloor:
1. Julia Stiles & Ezra Sosa
- Background: The iconic star of 10 Things I Hate About You brings cinematic grace and dramatic interpretation to the ballroom. Partnered with Ezra Sosa, Stiles has consistently impressed judges with her poise and performance quality, proving she is saving her best moves for the latter half of the season.
2. Giada De Laurentiis & Alan Bersten
- Background: The renowned celebrity chef is turning up the heat in the kitchen and on the dancefloor. Partnered with Alan Bersten, De Laurentiis has blended culinary precision with fiery Latin rhythms, keeping audiences guessing what style she will conquer next.
3. Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson
- Background: Known globally for his incredible musical theater and television pedigree in projects like Glee, Shum Jr. brings an advanced foundation of movement to Season 35. Paired with Jenna Johnson, he remains one of the technical powerhouses of the competition.
4. Taylor Hanson & Britt Stewart
- Background: The former ’90s teen heartthrob is hoping to "MMMBop" his way straight to the top of the leaderboard. Partnered with Britt Stewart, Hanson relies on nostalgic charm and infectious musicality to win over both judges and voters.
5. Tatyana Ali & Jan Ravnik
- Background: The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air actress is bringing authentic rhythm and fresh stage presence to the ballroom. Alongside pro partner Jan Ravnik, Ali has established herself as a consistent and formidable contender.
6. Jenna Dewan & Val Chmerkovskiy
- Background: Twenty years after capturing global attention as the star of the hit dance film Step Up, Dewan is stepping up to the ultimate ballroom challenge. Partnered with veteran pro Val Chmerkovskiy, her extensive background in dance places her among the favorites for the finale.
7. Amber Glenn & Pasha Pashkov
- Background: The 2026 Olympic figure skater is successfully translating her elite ice-skating balance, spins, and edge-work onto the hardwood floor. Paired with Pasha Pashkov, Glenn leverages her athletic training to master complex choreography.
8. Ezra Frech & Daniella Karagach
- Background: The Team USA Paralympic track and field athlete is redefining athleticism and accessibility in mainstream television. Partnered with Daniella Karagach, Frech continues to shatter expectations and inspire millions with his dynamic routines.
9. Sarah Jane Nader & Hailey Bills
- Background: Following in the footsteps of her sister Brooks Nader (who competed in Season 33), the Love Thy Nader star is stepping into the spotlight. Partnered with Hailey Bills, she brings youthful energy and a competitive spirit to the floor.
10. Connor Wood & Rylee Arnold
- Background: Better known to millions of digital natives as Fibula on social media, the comedian and content creator is translating online applause into live ballroom cheers. Partnered with Rylee Arnold, Wood relies on high-energy routines and undeniable screen charisma.
11. Conner Leavitt & Adele Zaikman
- Background: The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star is keeping a family tradition alive by following his wife, Whitney Leavitt (who competed in Season 34), into the franchise. Paired with Adele Zaikman, Leavitt is eager to carve out his own legacy in the ballroom.
12. Tyler Cameron & Sharna Burgess
- Background: The Bachelor Nation fan-favorite is officially trading in roses for rumbas. Partnered with veteran pro Sharna Burgess, Cameron combines height, frame, and mainstream appeal in his pursuit of ballroom glory.
13. Jackson Olson & Emma Slater
- Background: The professional baseball player for the Savannah Bananas is stepping up to a completely different kind of plate. Bringing the high-octane energy of baseball diamond entertainment into the studio, Olson and partner Emma Slater continue to deliver crowd-pleasing performances.
14. Ciara Miller & Brandon Armstrong
- Background: The Summer House star prepared extensively for her ballroom debut, noting ahead of the season that everyday stamina required serious gym conditioning. Partnered with Brandon Armstrong, Miller has focused on building the cardiovascular endurance necessary to sustain high-tempo routines.
"Looks are not indicative of being in shape," Ciara exclusively told E! News in June. "I do huff and puff going up the stairs, so I gotta get back into the gym and work on my stamina."
15. Maura Higgins & Mark Ballas
- Background: The Love Island UK alum manifested her spot on the show through deliberate intention, famously documenting her dreams on her annual vision boards. Partnered with the legendary Mark Ballas, Higgins has approached the competition with unwavering focus.
"I have a vision board and I redo it every year," she told E! News in May. "This year is the first year that I stayed at home by myself on New Year’s Eve… I made myself a bowl of pasta and a glass of red wine and I redid my vision board for the year. Dancing With the Stars was already on it from the year before. However, I added five more Dancing With the Stars on the board."
Future Outlook: What Lies Ahead for Season 35
As Season 35 of Dancing with the Stars pushes past its midpoint, the departure of Guillermo Rodriguez serves as a poignant reminder of what makes the franchise endure. It is a show where professional dancers act as sculptors, turning novices, athletes, chefs, and late-night sidekicks into temporary masters of the tango, foxtrot, and cha-cha.
While Rodriguez’s run has concluded, the ripples of his participation will likely influence future casting strategies across reality television. The fusion of late-night talk show culture with prime-time network competition proved to be a ratings and digital juggernaut, generating over 700,000 YouTube views and driving unprecedented online discourse.
For the remaining 15 couples, the path forward requires flawless execution, emotional connection, and the ability to capture public affection week after week. As the Mirrorball Trophy draws closer into view, the standard set by early fan-favorite exits like Rodriguez ensures that every remaining celebrity must leave everything they have on the dancefloor.
For the latest breaking news updates, behind-the-scenes exclusives, and live ballroom coverage, download the E! News App.