This investigation was produced in partnership with Deep South Today, a network of nonprofit, nonpartisan local newsrooms in Louisiana, Mississippi, and Arkansas.


Executive Overview

In the dead of a warm July night in 2015, a violent confrontation inside a pale-gray mobile home in Zachary, Louisiana, culminated in the death of Robert "Robbie" Noce. For the two young intruders—21-year-old Jace Crehan and 17-year-old Brittany Monk—the break-in was conceived as a desperate, misguided reckoning. Years earlier, Noce had subjected Monk to systematic, brutal sexual abuse starting when she was just four years old.

Yet, when the judicial system finally intervened in 2012, it offered little protection or closure. Following years of bureaucratic delays and institutional indifference, the East Baton Rouge Parish District Attorney’s office ultimately allowed Noce to plead no contest to a reduced charge of felony carnal knowledge of a juvenile. He received a suspended 10-year sentence and walked out of the courtroom a free man.

Terrified, deeply traumatized, and pregnant with Crehan’s child, Monk and Crehan took matters into their own hands. The resulting confrontation left Noce dead, and triggered a cascading tragedy that landed both teenagers in prison. While Crehan received a 35-year sentence after a successful appeal, Monk was sentenced to 35 years of hard labor for manslaughter—a staggering penalty handed down by a court that appeared eager to punish a victim who dared to step outside the legal boundaries of the state’s monopoly on force.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

Monk’s journey from a severely abused child to a criminalized survivor serving a decades-long prison sentence highlights a deeply entrenched crisis within the American legal system: the "abuse-to-prison pipeline" for girls and women. Her case exposes how institutions consistently fail to protect vulnerable children from abuse, only to marshal vast resources to punish them severely when they finally react to that violence.


Detailed Chronology: From Childhood Horror to the Night of July 3, 2015

A Childhood Forged in Abuse

Born in Baton Rouge in 1997 to a 15-year-old mother, Brittany Monk’s early life was defined by instability and trauma. Her mother, Maggie Dixon, was a victim of statutory rape who found herself homeless and bouncing between abusive partners across Louisiana and Arkansas. When Brittany was three, Robbie Noce—a family friend 14 years Dixon’s senior—invited Dixon and her toddler to live with him in Baker, Louisiana. Within a year, Dixon gave birth to Noce’s daughter, Kamron, before eventually leaving the household for good. Noce obtained sole custody of both girls.

Behind the closed doors of Noce’s trailer, life was strictly controlled. Noce systematically abused Brittany, utilizing over-the-counter sleep aids and prescription medications—which he referred to as "sweet medicine"—to render her unconscious before sexually assaulting her. When Brittany was roughly seven years old, Noce revealed he was not her biological father, conditioning her to accept the abuse under the threat that their family would be shattered and she would be separated from her half-sister, Kamron. By age 10, Noce was paying her small sums of money or giving her toys, grooming her to act as the "woman of the house."

The Broken Promise of the Legal System

When Brittany was 12, Dixon briefly returned to take custody of her, leaving Kamron behind with Noce. Plagued by guilt over abandoning her half-sister, Brittany eventually broke her silence during an argument with her mother in July 2012.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

"He raped me," Brittany told her mother.

The disclosure sparked a medical examination and a police investigation. On August 1, 2012, Noce was arrested and subsequently charged with aggravated rape. Officers executing a search warrant on his trailer seized handguns, marijuana paraphernalia, and massive quantities of drowsiness-inducing medications. During the investigation, an ex-girlfriend informed detectives that Noce had shown her child pornography stored on his computer. Kamron was swiftly removed from the home and placed with Dixon and Brittany.

Despite the gravity of the charges, the prosecution stalled. East Baton Rouge Parish District Attorney Hillar Moore’s office struggled to advance the case smoothly, while Dixon sent desperate emails to prosecutors expressing her fear that Noce would never face real punishment. In one bizarre exchange, a DA’s office employee offered Dixon a Thanksgiving meal and paper plates as compensation for the bureaucratic limbo.

By 2014, as she entered her mid-teens, Brittany grew increasingly anxious about the prospect of facing her abuser across a courtroom. Pregnant with Jace Crehan’s child in early 2015, and facing a high-risk pregnancy, Brittany informed prosecutors that she did not wish to endure a trial.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

In response, the DA’s office pursued a plea deal to spare her from testifying. On June 22, 2015, the charges against Noce were amended from aggravated rape to felony carnal knowledge of a juvenile. Noce entered a no-contest plea and was handed a 10-year sentence—which the judge promptly suspended. Noce walked out of the courthouse a free man on probation.

The Fatal Confrontation

The news that her abuser would face zero prison time triggered a psychological crisis for Brittany. Plagued by violent night terrors and fearing for the safety of her unborn child, Brittany and Crehan concluded that the state had failed them entirely.

On July 3, 2015, around 2 a.m., Crehan and a heavily pregnant Brittany walked over to Noce’s Zachary trailer. Crehan removed an air conditioner from a window to gain entry, and Brittany insisted on following him inside.

Awakened by the intrusion, Noce awoke disoriented and terrified. As Crehan attempted to subdue him, Noce grabbed a heavy rechargeable battery and struck Crehan in the head. A violent struggle ensued. According to court documents and Brittany’s recollections, Crehan instructed Brittany to fetch a knife and something to bind Noce. She retrieved a large kitchen knife and several ties from a doorway before retreating to the bathroom to dry heave as she listened to the sounds of the struggle.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

Emerging roughly 90 seconds later, Brittany found Noce motionless on the blood-soaked carpet. The couple fled, discarded their bloody clothes in a car wash trash receptacle, and threw the knife into a murky lake before attempting to resume their normal lives.


Supporting Context & Metrics: The Crisis of Criminalized Survival

The tragedy of Brittany Monk is not an isolated anomaly; it is a direct reflection of a systemic failure across the United States, and particularly in Louisiana.

The Abuse-to-Prison Pipeline

According to a landmark series of reports—including "The Sexual Abuse to Prison Pipeline," updated by the Georgetown Law Center on Gender Justice & Opportunity—up to 94 percent of women in detention facilities have experienced severe physical or sexual violence prior to their incarceration.

  • The Gendered Justice Gap: Research consistently demonstrates that the legal system routinely punishes women and girls without accounting for the context of coercive control, intimate partner violence, and childhood sexual abuse.
  • The Survivor-Offender Paradigm: The criminal legal system demands rigid, binary classifications: individuals are either victims or offenders. It systematically rejects the complex reality of "criminalized survivors"—those who commit offenses precisely because they were victims reacting to immediate threats or the catastrophic failures of protective institutions.
  • State Inaction vs. State Retribution: As journalist Justine van der Leun observed through comprehensive surveys of incarcerated women, a distinct pattern emerges: the state fails to protect victims of abuse, yet re-emerges with overwhelming prosecutorial force as soon as those victims attempt to defend themselves or seek extralegal closure.

Official Statements and Judicial Retribution

Following Noce’s death, local law enforcement quickly unraveled the crime. After initial denials, Crehan confessed to investigators, seeking to take full responsibility to protect Brittany. Instead, both were arrested and slapped with second-degree murder charges carrying mandatory life sentences without parole.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

The Prosecution’s Turnabout

As the state built its case, prosecutors who had once pursued Noce seemingly sought to undermine Brittany’s credibility regarding her childhood abuse. Assistant District Attorney Darwin Miller interrogated Brittany in a manner that recast her childhood survival strategies—such as accepting gifts and money from her abuser—as evidence of manipulation.

In December 2017, Brittany was forced to testify against Crehan in a courtroom overseen by retired Judge Anthony Marabella. During the proceedings, prosecutors openly questioned whether the historic rapes had ever occurred at all, effectively dismantling the very narrative they had relied upon years prior. Crehan was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole (a sentence later altered following a 2020 Supreme Court ruling banning non-unanimous juries).

The 35-Year Sentence

In January 2018, Brittany stood before Judge Marabella for sentencing on a reduced plea of manslaughter. Despite her mitigating circumstances—her status as a pregnant minor at the time of the crime, her history of severe trauma, and her lack of homicidal intent—Judge Marabella characterized her courtroom demeanor as "cold and emotionless" and expressed open skepticism regarding her abuse history. He handed down a sentence of 35 years of hard labor.

Defending the state’s aggressive posture at the time, District Attorney Hillar Moore emphasized the courts’ zero-tolerance stance on vigilantism. In a 2018 interview with CBS affiliate WAFB, Moore stated:

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

"The judge believed it was vigilante justice, and that’s something we can’t have with 104 murders last year… How would you like this to happen 104 other times to your family member or someone’s family member who loses someone as important as this one is to them?"


Future Outlook: A Second Chance?

Today, Brittany Monk is 27 years old and has served a decade behind bars. Her incarceration has been marked by remarkable self-rehabilitation: she earned her bachelor’s degree in social sciences through Tulane University correspondence courses, obtained a cosmetology license, and maintained a connection with her son, Vaan, who visits her regularly.

However, the legal landscape surrounding her case is beginning to shift.

  • Pro Bono Legal Representation: Defense attorney Jarrett Ambeau has taken on Brittany’s case pro bono, attempting to secure psychological evaluations to bring back to the District Attorney’s office for sentence reconsideration.
  • Legislative Reform: Ambeau is exploring a new Louisiana law—which went into effect on August 1—that explicitly requires courts and the state’s Board of Pardons to account for a defendant’s history as a victim of domestic abuse or sexual assault when reviewing sentences or clemency applications.
  • Family Support: Remarkably, Kamron—Noce’s daughter and Brittany’s half-sister—has publicly voiced her desire for Brittany to be released. "I grieve my dad every day still," Kamron noted, "but I just believe that people can change… I want my sister to come home."

Reflecting on her journey from a silenced, terrified child to an articulate woman fighting for her freedom, Brittany remains resolute.

Her Father Figure Raped Her As a Child. Then She Was Charged With His Murder

"I’ve been a victim of rape, but I’ve also been a victim of a system," Brittany says. "People minimize how much the system victimizes you and how many people are here because they were victims and they acted out because of that… I have earned a second chance."

By Nana Wu