The modern digital media landscape is frequently defined not just by the content creators produce, but by the high-stakes personal conflicts, network realignments, and bitter fallout narratives that transpire behind the scenes. Few modern digital media feuds have captured the public’s imagination quite like the fracture of the Call Her Daddy empire. Years after a tumultuous, highly publicized split in 2020 that effectively dissolved one of the most successful co-hosting duos in podcast history, former co-host Sofia Franklyn has reignited tensions.

As Franklyn prepares for the release of her revealing new memoir, Daddy Issues, she has publicly voiced deep concerns regarding behind-the-scenes retaliation. According to Franklyn, her former creative collaborator, Alex Cooper, and Cooper’s husband and business partner, Matt Kaplan, are allegedly working aggressively behind closed doors to discredit her narrative.

What began as a routine promotional tour for an upcoming book has quickly evolved into an escalating industry controversy. Franklyn’s allegations shed light on the cutthroat mechanics of modern digital media empires, where personal history, brand protection, and multi-million-dollar podcast networks collide. This report provides an in-depth investigative overview of Franklyn’s claims, the historical context of the Call Her Daddy split, the shifting power dynamics of the Unwell podcast network, and the broader implications of celebrity feuds in the influencer ecosystem.


Detailed Chronology of a Fractured Partnership

The Rise and Fall of Call Her Daddy (2018–2020)

To understand the gravity of Sofia Franklyn’s current warnings, one must look back at the meteoric rise and catastrophic implosion of Call Her Daddy. Launched in 2018 under Barstool Sports, the podcast quickly became a cultural touchstone for a generation of young women. Franklyn and Alex Cooper offered an unfiltered, brazen, and often controversial look at dating, sex, and twenty-something survival, amassing a fiercely loyal fanbase known as the "Daddy Gang."

However, creative differences and fierce contractual negotiations with Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy brought the podcast to a screeching halt in the spring of 2020. While Cooper ultimately opted to accept a new deal that kept the Call Her Daddy intellectual property under the Barstool umbrella, Franklyn sought an exit, leading to a permanent rift between the co-hosts.

In her Hulu docuseries, Call Her Alex, Cooper reflected on the pivotal juncture: "Sofia didn’t want to take the deal, but I did, so I stayed. I realized the ‘Daddy Gang’ was bigger than both of us."

The Post-Split Landscape and the Unwell Network

Following the 2020 division, Cooper’s career soared. She eventually transitioned Call Her Daddy away from Barstool Sports in a landmark, multi-million-dollar deal with Spotify, subsequently establishing the Unwell podcast network alongside her husband, Matt Kaplan. Under Cooper’s stewardship, Unwell expanded to incorporate multiple high-profile creators, turning Cooper into a powerhouse executive producer and media mogul.

Conversely, Franklyn faced an uphill battle rebuilding her media presence. Launching her independent venture, Sofia with an F, she navigated the challenging waters of solo podcasting. Over the years, Franklyn has remained candid about the psychological and professional toll of the initial fallout, making her upcoming memoir, Daddy Issues, a crucial milestone in reclaiming her narrative.

The Memoir Reveal and Retaliation Claims

The tension reached a boiling point on November 9, during an appearance on The Bossticks podcast. Franklyn revealed that as she prepares to release Daddy Issues, she has received intelligence that individuals prominently featured in the book—specifically naming Alex Cooper and Matt Kaplan—are actively working to undermine her credibility.

"I have heard that some people mentioned in the book, some main characters in my book, are working very hard to discredit this story," Franklyn stated. "I thought I was bulletproof, and then I started to think how dirty are they gonna play?"

Addressing Cooper and Kaplan directly, Franklyn added, "I’m talking about Alex and Matt, hi. And if you’re listening, hi."

Rather than focusing solely on professional critique, Franklyn expressed genuine alarm regarding how far the retaliation might extend into her personal life. "Are they gonna go after people I love?" she questioned. "That, I do not like. If my family, my husband, becomes collateral, that actually scares me." She noted that these anxieties have punctured the armor she initially planned to wear during her book rollout, admitting, "I thought I was gonna go into this process being like, two middle fingers in the air… We’ll see how that plays out."


Supporting Context & Industry Metrics

The Mechanics of Modern Media Retaliation

Franklyn’s concerns highlight an increasingly common phenomenon in the influencer economy: the weaponization of public relations and private network connections to control a narrative. According to Franklyn, sophisticated media operators know precisely how to undermine a dissenting voice during a high-profile book release.

"If someone’s playing really gnarly, they are reaching out to your college roommates, people you worked with, people that you’ve had two, maybe one experience with," Franklyn explained, outlining her fears of preemptive smear campaigns. "And they’re asking them, ‘What can you tell me about this person?’ And then I don’t know exactly how they’ll try to flip it."

Despite these tactical fears, Franklyn remains resolute. She noted that she approached Daddy Issues with absolute transparency, vowing to confront memories and actions even when the truth is "embarrassing," "shameful," or "horrible" to look back on. "I’m going to be real as f–k," she asserted.

Broader Scrutiny Surrounding the Unwell Network

Franklyn is not the only prominent media personality to publicly question the corporate culture and operational tactics of Alex Cooper’s Unwell empire. In recent months, the network has faced heightened scrutiny from former affiliates and industry observers.

Notably, influencer Alix Earle accused Cooper of "sick and twisted" behavior following the fallout over Earle’s canceled podcast, Hot Mess. The public friction escalated when Earle co-signed a viral TikTok post accusing Cooper of employing an "ambulance chaser" approach—allegedly capitalizing on vulnerable or distressed podcast guests to drive network growth. While Cooper publicly invited Earle to air her grievances openly rather than through "passive aggressive reposts," the public clashes underscore a growing counter-narrative surrounding Cooper’s aggressive ascent in the podcasting industry.

Franklyn believes these compounding controversies may ultimately work in her favor. She noted that consumers and digital audiences are increasingly media-literate. "It’s going to be a lot harder to discredit me now because the audience is smarter now," Franklyn observed, pointing out that internet users are "slightly more aware of how media PR headlines work" than they were during the initial 2020 split.


Official Statements and Industry Response

As of publication, representatives for Alex Cooper and Matt Kaplan have not formally responded to E! News regarding Franklyn’s latest allegations of behind-the-scenes sabotage and intimidation. Cooper’s camp has historically maintained a strict corporate and legal boundary regarding public discussions of the 2020 Barstool Sports departure, choosing instead to focus public messaging on the ongoing commercial success of the Unwell network and Call Her Daddy.

Industry analysts note that while Cooper commands immense mainstream visibility through high-profile celebrity interviews and lucrative corporate partnerships, independent creators like Franklyn often leverage long-form print publishing to bypass traditional digital gatekeepers and offer unfiltered counter-narratives.


Future Outlook

The release of Daddy Issues marks a critical juncture for Sofia Franklyn. By stepping back into the ring and confronting her past directly, she is challenging a media machine that has largely favored the commercial dominance of her former co-host.

However, the road ahead remains fraught with interpersonal and professional risks. As Franklyn navigates the promotional circuit, the central question is whether the public and her loyal listeners will embrace her version of events, or if the alleged behind-the-scenes PR maneuvers will successfully complicate the rollout of her memoir.

What is certain is that the fracture between Sofia Franklyn and Alex Cooper is no longer just a relic of early-pandemic podcast history. It has evolved into a protracted narrative war—one that underscores the fragile nature of digital partnerships and the immense stakes involved when multi-million-dollar brands are built on personal histories. As Daddy Issues hits shelves, readers and media watchers alike will be watching closely to see how the Unwell network leadership responds, and whether Franklyn’s unvarnished truth can withstand the corporate machinery aligned against it.