Nearly six years after the seismic industry fracture that ended one of digital media’s most successful partnerships, Sofia Franklyn’s new memoir pulls back the curtain on the betrayal, corporate maneuvering, and psychological fallout that defined the rise and fall of Call Her Daddy.


Executive Overview

It has been nearly six years since the digital media landscape was rocked by the sudden, catastrophic dissolution of Call Her Daddy. At its peak, the podcast was a cultural juggernaut, serving as the crown jewel of Barstool Sports and pulling in millions of weekly downloads from an obsessive audience weaned on raw, unfiltered takes on modern dating, sexual autonomy, and millennial female bravado.

Yet, beneath the meteoric success and raunchy humor, a toxic machinery was grinding away. In 2020, contract negotiations with Barstool owner Dave Portnoy went off the rails, culminating in a bitter public divorce that left co-host Alex Cooper with the IP, a multimillion-dollar empire, and eventual Spotify deals worth tens of millions. Meanwhile, co-host Sofia Franklyn was left with nothing—ostracized, heavily criticized online, and effectively erased from the brand she helped build.

While Alex Cooper has largely risen to the status of podcasting royalty—cementing her dominance through her expansive Unwell network—the exact mechanics of the show’s demise have remained shrouded in competing narratives, social media posturing, and corporate spin.

Enter Daddy Issues: A Memoir. Out now via major retailers in paperback, Kindle, and audiobook formats, the book represents Franklyn’s definitive, unvarnished attempt to reclaim her history. Moving far beyond the soundbites of yesteryear, the memoir tackles her early struggles with substance abuse, the insidious erosion of her friendship with Cooper, secret corporate backroom deals, and the profound psychological toll of being digitally flayed by millions. Far from a simple Hollywood tell-all, Daddy Issues offers a chilling, forensic look at the dark side of digital fame and the brutal realities of modern media contracts.


Detailed Chronology: From Unlikely Roommates to Industry Titans

The Genesis of a Phenomenon (2018)

The partnership between Sofia Franklyn and Alex Cooper began in 2018 through a serendipitous encounter in a New York City rideshare. Franklyn, reeling from a failed stint as an analyst at Morgan Stanley and navigating a lonely transition to Manhattan, was introduced to Cooper via a mutual acquaintance. The two instantly bonded, moving in together and quickly forming a codependent "package deal."

Recognizing a distinct gap in the market for unfiltered, raunchy female-centric audio content, the duo partnered with the digital production entity Podible to launch Call Her Daddy. Within four episodes, their chemistry caught the attention of Dave Portnoy. Eager to expand Barstool Sports’ demographic reach, Portnoy swooped in with an offer.

The Original Barstool Deal and Early Red Flags

The initial three-year contract offered by Barstool Sports seemed lucrative to two relative unknowns: starting at $75,000 in the first year, scaling to $85,000, and $100,000 in the third, supplemented by $2,500 bonuses for every 10 percent increase in downloads. However, the deal contained a foundational trap: Barstool acquired the intellectual property (IP) rights to Call Her Daddy, including the name, show archives, and social media channels.

While Franklyn’s mother advised her to shop the show around for better leverage, Cooper pushed for immediate execution. Franklyn signed, sealing the fate of the show’s ownership.

Sofia Franklyn Reveals the Dark Side of 'Call Her Daddy' in Explosive Memoir: 9 Biggest Bombshells

Internal fissures began to manifest shortly thereafter. According to the memoir, Cooper’s childhood best friend and third roommate, Lauren, pulled Franklyn aside early on to deliver a stark warning: Cooper was utilizing Franklyn primarily for social currency and status elevation. "You showed up and it was like I never existed," Lauren reportedly warned, noting that Cooper had a history of discarding people once they no longer served her upward trajectory.

The Christmas Party Fallout and Secret Moves

A pivotal turning point arrived during a Barstool company Christmas party. Overwhelmed by anxiety and heavy drinking, Franklyn suffered a blackout evening that left her wracked with dread the following morning. When she sought to clear the air, Cooper informed her that she had been "rude" and "aggressive," claiming that Dave Portnoy was actively seeking to fire her.

Stricken with panic, Franklyn offered to apologize directly to Portnoy. Instead, Cooper allegedly steered her toward a family-recommended psychiatrist who prescribed naltrexone to curb alcohol cravings. Yet, when Franklyn finally spoke with Portnoy and Barstool executives, she discovered a stark disconnect: executive leadership was nowhere near as incensed as Cooper had claimed.

Subsequent intelligence revealed a darker manipulation. Cooper had allegedly approached Portnoy immediately after the party to lobby for Franklyn’s termination. When that failed, Cooper leveraged the friction to negotiate a private pay raise for herself, telling a former podcast employee, "If I have to put up with her, I need more money. So she got the raise."

The 2020 Renegotiation and the Birth of "The Fathers"

By 2020, Call Her Daddy was generating an estimated $11 million annually for Barstool, completely outstripping the value of their initial contract. Bound by restrictive clauses that barred them from executing external book deals, alcohol sponsorships, or live tours, the co-hosts moved to renegotiate.

Their legal team drafted a bold proposal demanding a 50/50 revenue split on all IP exploitation and a guaranteed minimum of $1 million per year for each host.

During a strategic retreat designed to align their business goals, Franklyn and Cooper reaffirmed their mutual commitment. Facing the possibility that Barstool would strip them of the Call Her Daddy IP if negotiations collapsed, the pair agreed to walk away together and launch a successor show tentatively titled The Fathers. They were, in their minds, a united front.

The Ultimate Betrayal and the Collapse

The united front crumbled under the weight of corporate maneuvering. In the spring of 2020, while Franklyn believed they were locked in a unified standoff with management, Cooper covertly negotiated a separate arrangement with Portnoy.

Portnoy later revealed to Franklyn that Cooper had approached him independently, presenting a plan to continue Call Her Daddy alone while branding Franklyn as the unreasonable obstacle holding up the deal. Portnoy offered Franklyn a consolation prize—her own standalone podcast under the Barstool umbrella—assuring her of full production support. Feeling deeply betrayed by both her co-host and the network, Franklyn rejected the offer.

Sofia Franklyn Reveals the Dark Side of 'Call Her Daddy' in Explosive Memoir: 9 Biggest Bombshells

The fallout was swift and brutal. Cooper locked Franklyn out of the show’s social media accounts and published a 52-minute YouTube exposé titled The Truth About Call Her Daddy, branding Franklyn a "liability." The public narrative instantly cast Cooper as the victim and Franklyn as a greedy saboteur.


Supporting Context & Metrics

  • Financial Scale: At the time of the 2020 split, Call Her Daddy was driving immense enterprise value for Barstool Sports, pulling in millions of downloads weekly and anchoring the network’s advertising revenue.
  • The Aftermath Valuation: While Franklyn eventually launched Sofia with an F—initially backed by a reported $500,001 offer—Cooper parlayed her retention of the IP into massive syndication and distribution deals, eventually signing a reported $60 million exclusive agreement with Spotify and launching the Unwell media network.
  • Personal Toll: The media storm coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic, forcing Franklyn into seclusion in Utah, where she battled severe paranoia, high-profile relationship fractures, and the personal grief of a secret abortion just days before a birthday trip to the Amalfi Coast—all while watching Cooper monetize catchphrases derived from Franklyn’s own personal anecdotes.

Official Statements and Responses

Thus far, the primary vehicle for this chapter of the saga is Franklyn’s own words in Daddy Issues. In previous statements to 1,200-word investigative features and media outlets like Rolling Stone, Dave Portnoy maintained that Franklyn "can’t get her story straight," while Alex Cooper has largely pivoted away from direct engagement, transitioning from scorched-earth accusations to a position of corporate and cultural hegemony.

However, the release of the memoir has already reignited legal tensions. According to Franklyn, the very day her memoir was announced, her literary agent received an aggressive phone call from Matt Kaplan—Alex Cooper’s husband—threatening legal action.

Reflecting on the threat in her memoir, Franklyn writes:

"I remember this feeling of powerlessness. Alex rearranging my life with no acknowledgment. My life being taken, overnight. On the scoreboard of Alex vs. Sofia, Alex won. I cannot fathom her trying to do it again… I feel bulletproof… something born out of a dark place. For the first time I have something Alex wants. Our story. My story."


Future Outlook: Reclaiming the Narrative

The publication of Daddy Issues marks a critical watershed moment in the evolution of influencer and creator economies. For years, the digital space has operated in a lawless frontier where intellectual property rights, friendship, and corporate exploitation routinely collide behind closed doors.

By detailing the inner workings of a multi-million-dollar podcasting breakup, Franklyn’s memoir does more than settle old scores; it provides a cautionary playbook for emerging digital creators. It underscores the vital importance of independent legal counsel, ironclad contract protections regarding IP ownership, and the psychological hazards of tying one’s personal identity to corporate-owned brands.

As Daddy Issues climbs bestseller lists and re-ignites public discourse across social media platforms, the power dynamic between the former co-hosts has shifted once again. Alex Cooper may hold the financial crown and the Spotify empire, but Sofia Franklyn has successfully reclaimed the pen—ensuring that the true history of Call Her Daddy will forever bear her signature.